The 1 mistake online writers make after a “bad” social post


Writing on social is unpredictable.

Amount of times I’ve written up what I think is a freaking legendary post, then it bombs or doesn’t blow up like I thought it would?

100s of times.

Easy to get disheartened.

Especially when you’re just getting started and every post feels like you’re putting yourself on a billboard for everyone to see.

The mistake most online writers make though?

They don’t learn from “bad” posts.

But after writing 10,000+ social posts, I’m numb to the feeling of “bad” posts.

I’ve learned to turn those “bad” posts into data and learn from them.

Here’s the 3 steps I take to turn “bad” posts, learn from them and become a better social writer:

Step 1. I analyse why it didn’t work

There’s always a reason the post didn’t hit.

So I check:

  • Was the hook good enough?
  • Do people actually care about the topic?
  • Did I write concisely enough?
  • Did it create a specific emotional reaction?

9 times out of 10 the hook could’ve been better.

But a mental checkover like this puts improvements top of mind for the next post.

Step 2. I challenge myself to keep experimenting

You’ll never see me not testing and trying new things.

If a post sucks, so what?

I don’t need to panic and protect my ego. In my eyes if you’re not testing or trying new things every now and then, then you’re not moving forward.

Yes, repurpose winning content. Yes, double down on hits.

But keep 10-20% back for experimenting.

Push your creativity, find new ways to connect with your audience.

Step 3. I remind myself that it doesn’t matter

I wrote about this recently that 0.07% of my all time LinkedIn posts have generated over 14% of my all time views.

Wild init?

Makes you realise that consistent posting is more important than anything and letting the social media gods decide your fate is the way to go.

The more you write, the more chance something will hit.

And even if it doesn’t hit, who ACTUALLY cares?

If your whole business is entirely reliant on if today’s social post goes viral or not, then you should probably figure out a new business strategy.

That ain’t sustainable.

TL;DR:

  1. I analyze what didn’t resonate
  2. I challenge myself to keep experimenting
  3. I remind myself that it doesn’t matter

I hope this opens your eyes.

Because I see even the most talented social writers freaking out over “bad” posts.

Every bad post is a chance to get better.

Keep writing, adjusting and showing up.

Cheers,

Matt Barker

P.S. did you miss The 5 Minute Daily Writing System Training this week? If you did, then you can grab the replay + training doc for free here.

Follow my socials → LinkedIn / Twitter / Threads / Substack

Read past newsletters & shop products → Browse

Sponsor this newsletter → Book a slot

Unsubscribe / Update your email preferences / 113 Cherry St #92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2205

Matt Barker

Join 11,000+ readers of The Digital Writer for no-nonsense tips, strategies and advice to attract your dream clients with social copywriting.

Read more from Matt Barker

Yesterday I remembered how annoying it was when I'd post on social and get basically no likes or comments (from anyone, not even the right people). I'd put the effort in, but no results. Are you in the same boat right now? You are not alone. I’ve been there too.(remember everyone started zero, doesn't matter where they are now). I'd wonder why my content wasn’t landing with the audience I wanted to attract. And let's be real, it sucks. But over time, I realised it wasn’t about working harder...

I’ve been writing on LinkedIn since January 2022. At the point of writing this it's October 2024, so that brings my online writing journey up to 34 months. Then consider I've posted at least 7 times per week since then, and we're up to around 1,000 pieces of content JUST on LinkedIn. But sometimes, my posts don’t land the way I expect. And it’s demoralizing. When you think you’re sharing gold, but the audience doesn’t react. That feeling isn't reserved for newbies - it still hits occasionally...

Before we dive in... Spend too much time writing content? Need a faster way to write consistently? Tomorrow you can join me (Matt Barker) on a free Zoom training called "The 5 Minute Daily Writing System". I'll show you step by step how I write long form, educational content every day from just 5 minutes of writing. Over 70 folks are signed up already, join us here. There’s a lot of advice out there about creating content without selling. But here’s the thing: If you want to make money, you...